GOODBYE TO THE TRUMP YEARS: A WAKE-UP CALL FOR DEMOCRACY

We have learned from history that Fascists can reach high office via elections. When they do, the first step they attempt is to undermine the authority of competing power centers, including parliament or in America, Congress.

                                                         -Madeleine Albright (Fascism: A Warning p. 234)

We haven’t written enough about preserving American democracy. The January 6 occupation of the U.S. Capitol by a mob inspired by President Donald Trump brought home to us why we must write about that subject regularly, beginning now.

Some might think Trump’s imminent exit from the White House and installation of a new administration will assuage concerns about threats to democratic values and institutions. On the contrary, we think the end

of the Trump presidency presents a perfect opportunity for examining what happened the last four years and what Americans must do that will ensure democracy remains our form of government.

 

A Tortured Four Years

We think Trump has been wrong about environmental protection, voting rights, immigration, criminal justice, taxes, and many other policies. That’s not what we mean by a “tortured four years.” No, we refer to his assaults on democracy as a governing ideology.

His attack on democracy as our basic form of government constitutes the greatest sin of his time in office. He has put supporting evidence for that claim on constant display. 

                       

The January 6 insurrection, spurred by an incendiary speech in which he urged that thousands march on the capitol in support of his bogus voter fraud claims while Congress tabulated the Electoral College votes, stands as exhibit “A.” The resulting 

carnage, thanks largely to a massive security failure, left at least five people dead, the capitol building ransacked, and a huge black mark on American democracy and its standing in the world.  Comparisons to December 7, 1941, and September 11, 2001, as dark days in the nation’s history weren’t inappropriate. There’s lots more:      

·     The Phone Call. On January 2, Trump called

the Georgia Secretary of State asking that he “find” votes that would overturn President–elect Biden’s victory there. He asked that election officials “recalculate” the returns and give him the votes that would reverse the outcome in the Peach State. Search as many did for a benign explanation or interpretation of Trump’s words, none appeared. It was extortion of the kind more commonly associated with mob bosses and Mafia dons. First readings of federal and Georgia election statutes suggested he crossed the line into criminal misconduct; 

·     Misusing Congress. To avoid the peaceful transfer of power his defeat requires, Trump enticed Republican members of the House and Senate to challenge duly certified electors, leading to the January 6 riot. He challenged votes in Milwaukee, Philadelphia, and Atlanta, overwhelmingly black cities, in a blatant attempt at marginalizing the black

vote standing  between him and his effort to turn America into an autocracy. This largely unprecedented action followed a string of over 50 defeats in lawsuits he brought aimed at throwing out votes or advancing unsupported voter fraud claims;

·     Misusing the pardon power. His granting of

pardons and commutations to cronies, family members, and business associates who have committed crimes against the United States demonstrates his contempt for democracy, democratic institutions, democratic norms, and the rule of law;

·     Attacking the judiciary. Trump’s initial assault on a federal judge of Mexican descent began an attempt to drive a wedge between Latinos and other Americans while diminishing respect for the judiciary;

·     Denigrating America’s world standing. By reducing our commitment to NATO,

Trump hoped he could free the United States from democratic norms NATO members must follow, thereby making easier alliances with autocrats;

·     Kowtowing to Vladimir Putin. Trump would not criticize Russian interference in the 2016 election and he took Putin’s side against the

findings of U.S. intelligence agencies that Russia meddled in that election. When reports surfaced of Putin putting bounties on U.S. soldiers, Trump said nothing. When cyber experts uncovered a massive computer hacking almost certainly carried out by the Russians, Trump, without evidence, blamed it on China;

· Ukraine. Trump’s refusal to release appropriated funds for Ukraine’s defense

against Russian aggression unless the Ukrainians helped him dig up dirt on his domestic political opponents evidenced his autocratic preferences and disregard for the American constitution;

·     Personalizing the Justice Department. Trump’s conversion of the Attorney General from the people’s lawyer to his personal counsel flagrantly abused his power and undermined the rule of law; and

·     Misuse of the military. By ordering that U.S. troops clear peaceful protesters from Lafayette Park in Washington for his photo op, Trump demonstrated the true nature of his autocratic tendencies.   

 

Lessons

Listing Trump’s bad acts represents only a first step. We remain far from knowing all we should about his assault on democracy. As we learn more, we’ll say more about what happened and about what we should do.

We began with former State Secretary Madeline Albright’s observation abouthow fascists acquire power, even in democratic systems. We turn to her book again as we close:

When we awaken each morning, we see around the globe what appears to be Fascism’s early stirrings: the discrediting of mainstream politicians, the emergence of leaders who seek to divide rather than to unite, the pursuit of political victory at all costs, and the invocation of national greatness by people who seem to possess only a warped concept of what greatness means. (p. 118)

We think Secretary Albright’s warning is for us, as in U.S.